Everyone's talking about brand authenticity these days. It's gone way beyond a simple marketing buzzword. We all know it's not just about a catchy tagline or a cool logo. It's about how a company's stated values actually translate into real, tangible actions. But how do companies actually achieve this? And what role do employees play in making brand authenticity more than just a surface-level claim?
In this episode of Marketing Science Lab, we're diving deep into a fascinating new study from the Journal of Brand Management that explores the often-overlooked connection between brand authenticity and employee behavior. We're talking about the difference between employees just going through the motions and those who genuinely go above and beyond for customers (Lim, 2024).
This research challenges the assumption that simply telling employees to believe in the brand is enough to magically motivate them. Just like you can tell when someone genuinely believes in what they're selling versus reciting a script, customers can sense when a company's actions don't align with its stated values.
The Study: Frontline Employees in Branded Hotels
The researchers studied frontline employees at branded hotels in India and their findings were surprising. They discovered there was no direct link between how authentic a brand felt and whether or not the employees went the extra mile. This means that a strong, authentic brand doesn't automatically lead to employees feeling more motivated or invested – there are other crucial ingredients at play.
What's particularly noteworthy about this study is its methodology. It wasn't just about surveys; they observed real employee behavior to understand the nuances of brand authenticity and its impact.
The Secret Ingredients: Empowerment and Commitment
The study revealed two key ingredients needed for brand authenticity to truly translate into positive actions:
Psychological Empowerment: Employees need to feel empowered, like they have the power to make a real difference in their roles. Their actions need to matter. It's not enough to just believe in the brand's message; they need to believe they can personally create positive impact through their work. If they feel like another cog in the machine, why would they go above and beyond? Their efforts would feel meaningless.
Organizational Commitment: It's not enough for employees to just love the product or service; they have to believe in the company itself. They need to believe in the company's values, mission, and culture. Employees need to feel like they are part of something bigger than themselves, something they can be proud of. This helps explain why companies known for having incredibly loyal employees often nail that sense of shared purpose and commitment.
The Counterintuitive Finding: Too Much Autonomy Can Backfire
Here's where things get really interesting, maybe even a little counterintuitive. The study also found that too much autonomy at work could actually have a negative effect. We're constantly being told that autonomy equals freedom, happiness, and better performance. So, what's the deal?
Imagine being asked to bake a cake but not being given a recipe, ingredients, or even an oven, and then being judged on how it tastes. You'd be set up for failure from the start! That's what unstructured autonomy can feel like for employees.
Without the right support and guidance, that sense of freedom can actually lead to anxiety, fear of failure, and even a sense of feeling adrift. It's about finding the right balance, the sweet spot between autonomy and structure.
Actionable Takeaways for Leaders and Employees
So, what does all of this mean for leaders and employees? Here are some valuable takeaways:
For Leaders and Managers:
Don't just talk about authenticity – live it internally. If your company says they value transparency, but all the big decisions are made behind closed doors, it's brand inconsistency. Employees will notice.
Provide structure alongside autonomy. Think of it as "guided autonomy," providing the resources, training, and support employees need to make good decisions and take initiative. And when they do, celebrate those wins!
For Frontline Employees:
You have more power than you realize. You are the face of the brand, interacting with customers every day. You shape their entire perception, for better or worse.
If you're feeling a disconnect between a company's values and actions, speak up! Provide constructive feedback, come to the table with solutions. Be part of the solution. Explain how you see things and how things could be done differently to align with those brand values. Your feedback could be the catalyst for real change.
Brand Authenticity: Beyond Business
This research also sparked a powerful question: What if these principles of authenticity, empowerment, and commitment are bigger than just business? What about our own personal brands? How we show up in our lives, relationships, and communities? Are we bringing our most authentic selves to the table in every aspect of our lives?
Do we feel empowered to make a difference in our own circles? Are we truly committed to the things, people, and causes that matter most to us? It's not just about companies, right? These concepts can absolutely apply to how we live our lives every single day. Maybe, just maybe, exploring those questions is the key to living a more authentic, more impactful, and ultimately more fulfilling life.
Interactive Study Guide: https://quizlet.com/study-guides/brand-authenticity-and-employee-engagement-insights-ffe5593c-3cb0-484d-9ce8-9671cf66d876?i=3i62em&x=13qt
Source:
Lim, W., Malik, N., Gupta, S. et al. Harnessing brand authenticity to promote prosocial service behavior. Journal of Brand Management 31, 449–468 (2024). https://doi.org/10.1057/s41262-024-00352-1
Share this post